Don’t get me wrong, I love the man.
Joe Torre has always been a kind and warm individual who has never turned his back on the NYC media despite the amount of pressure put upon him. His track record has been debated at length and the numbers speak for themselves…And the playoff losses are not his fault.
These days, the post-season is more or less a crap shoot anyway…can you blame a guy for getting to the holy land of the playoffs and not delivering the grail? Three rounds, each of which require you to have no more than two stud pitchers, can see months of hard work turn fruitless with a few bad breaks. Even the Yankees of the 20s through the early 60s would have walked away losers more often than not if they had to go three rounds instead of one.
It’s not Joe’s fault by any stretch, but it’s time for him to go — and get replaced by another Italian ex-catcher with the same first name.
Simply, the Yankees need change and some youthful managing to go with their youthful roster. A-Rod will be gone because the Yanks won’t pay him, but Pettitte, Posada and Rivera may all stay if they bring in the right man. Joe Girardi.
It may all come full circle. Just as Girardi aided in the grooming of his eventual replacement, Posada, Torre may very well have educated his successor in Girardi. We all know that since 1996, when Girardi first arrived with the Yankees, that ‘he would one day make a great manager’. Well, catchers often do. Girardi has already won manager of the year in Florida for taking a group of young players and putting them on the fringe of a playoff birth in 2006. He’s just the man to take a roster full of young and talented Yankees and get the most from them.
Phil Hughes, Joba Rules!, Ian Kennedy, Chein-Ming Wang…four young arms who are all right up Girardi’s ally. Cano, Melky, Duncan, Phillips…kids that can work with Joe G.
Now, what about the Torre-loyal vets who can walk this year?
As young pitchers, Pettitte and Rivera learned to throw at a big league level with Girardi catching. Meanwhile, Posada may owe much of his career to the selfless tutoring Girardi gave him.
Simply, he’s a man who these Yankees can play for. And unlike Torre, his energy and passion for the game are still fresh. That’s not to say that Torre wasn’t giving his all until the end. Absolutely not the case. But the Yankees need a breath of fresh air right now. And their old catcher is just the man to do it.